
There are so many things in our Christian walk that are guided by the Holy Spirit and not by “commands” from scripture. And I’ve found over many years of walking with Christ, that those things don’t always align from Christian to Christian. It’s one of the causes of division in the body of Christ—that we too often turn, like Peter, and look at our brothers and sisters and say to Jesus, “But what about him?”
I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately in what I share about my reading life. You see, while I read a lot of Christian fiction, I don’t just read Christian fiction. I read a lot of general market fiction, too.
Not indiscriminately, mind you. I’ve put down many a book because I just can’t read that story or that level of description or language. But I do have a tolerance level for both that I’ve set in my mind and feel at peace with in my spirit. I even recommend some of these books in my monthly mini-reviews, with the caveat of what they contain, so that no one goes into them without that knowledge.
But why do I even do that much? Why do I wade through the beginnings of books I don’t finish or books that aren’t written from a Christian worldview?
Here are a couple of my top reasons:
I remember many years ago, I picked up a general market book called Sarah’s Key. I had no reason to read it. I didn’t know the author. Hadn’t even heard of the book. It was WWII fiction, and I loved the story. A few weeks later, I was talking to a woman I didn’t know, and we ended up on the subject of books.
“Have you read Sarah’s Key?” she asked.
“As a matter of fact, I have!”
We went on to have a conversation about it.

I can’t tell you how many, many times this has happened to me. Books and reading are my most comfortable subjects around people I don’t know. And so incredibly often, these conversations will circle around to a general market book I just happen to have read! Or sometimes, if I’m getting to know a new friend and they recommend a work of general market fiction, I will read in order to get to know them better.
This seems to be how the Holy Spirit allows me to converse with people I don’t know. Not only do books give me a connection with the person, but they often open the door for me to share my faith in some way—sometimes with my words in the moment, but often by recommending Christian fiction in a similar genre to the book we happen to have in common.
Another reason I like to read general market fiction is to keep my finger on the pulse of culture. I like to see what the general population is reading and how it portrays life and relationships and meaning. Books give me a much better understanding of that, which also helps me have a heart of compassion for a world that doesn’t know Christ.

Finally, not all authors who are Christians write for Christian publishers. I love when I know an author who writers general market books. Or when I find general market books that are written from a perspective of redemption. I don’t want to miss out on those great stories even though they don’t come out of a “Christian” publishing house.
I will say that I can’t read too many general market (non-Christian worldview) books in a row without feeling the need to “cleanse my palate” with a story—or several!—rooted in faith. I’m so grateful for quality Christian fiction that I can enjoy and recommend to others without reservation!

Like so many other things, the Lord has me living by faith in my reading choices, allowing Him to guide and direct those for His purposes—and to have grace for those the Holy Spirit is guiding to different choices. I’m grateful we can all be readers together!
Have your reading choices changed through the years? What are your parameters now?


I can relate to every word! I write from a Christian worldview with the hope of enticing a reader to find out what Christians are really all about so we can point to Jesus! And raising young boys in this culture, I have to know what’s going into their precious minds so I can face it with calm truth. What’s selling in the general market is a good indication. I have no qualms putting a book down, and I make sure I’m in the Word daily. Because that’s really the only book that matters. Thank you for your insights, D’Ann.
I so agree about God’s Word! If I weren’t in that book so often, I could so easily be enticed by worldviews contrary to God. It’s the unmovable standard by which I measure everything!
I also read widely, exploring both Christian and secular books. As a writer, I want to glean wisdom from great writers. As a Christian, I want, as you say, to be able to converse with and lean in to those who are lost. I joined a secular book club specifically to find moments to interact and exhibit faith. In Jordan Raynor’s book, Five Mere Christians, he talks about our need to insulate, not isolate, from the world. We wear a coat so that we can go out into the cold. The Word insulates us from the world, while allowing us to be salt and light in the world. If we isolate, how do we reach them? Thanks for all your book recommendations.
I love that coat analogy! So very true. I know reading widely is not for every Christian, but I love it when those of us who do have very specific “callings” to read other things can do so through the lens of God’s Word.
I love to read widely. I am my church’s librarian and I like to stay in touch with what my contemporaries are reading. I try to read every book before I add it to the church collection and sometimes I just need a different perspective. Thank you for this great piece,
I love that you take that job so seriously! A church library should be an especially safe place for readers of all spiritual maturity levels!
I’ve discovered Katherine Reay this year and love her writing. Clean writing from the general writing world. Interesting and thought provoking. Berlin Letter and The English Masterpiece . I’ve read one Amy Harmon and had to skip a section but good writer same with Kristin Hannah. My mind just doesn’t need to go to some places. So thanks for sharing your experiences. Christian fiction is my favorite and historical is my favorite genre. I’ve become addicted to Colleen Cobble some with Rick Acker. Although now historical .
Ann, I have all your beginning books and looked for you after I finished the first four. Anne Matter all were great and in my kindle forever!! Plus a couple of your recent books. Thanks for sharing your insights. It’s where I get ideas for new books.
You are very sweet, Pam! I’m so glad you enjoyed my books!
Yes, Katherine Reay is one of those who actually started out writing Christian fiction but has transitioned to the general market and kept her books clean. And they are so good!